Second Chair

The Bench

Two insurers. Both files. One determination.

Link the case packs and opinions both claims teams already hold. Second Chair reviews the facts, the merit, and the documents, then returns one determination both sides can use.

After each team has an opinion

The Bench is for the moment two insurers are looking at the same collision and each has already worked the file. Deep Dive stays the path for a single claims team. The Bench starts when both organisations put those packs and opinions forward together.

Second Chair reads the joint record with the disagreements left in place. Where the facts, the opinions, or the documents conflict, the conflict stays on the record. A separate red team then tries to break that reading.

The determination states the apportionment, the reasons, and what each file established. Both claims teams receive the same result, and a person at each insurer still decides what to do with it.

The path

Facts, merit, documents — then the attack

The same order as careful counsel: see the whole record, test it, then speak.

Insurer A

Case pack and opinion Facts, documents, and the opinion that team already holds.

Insurer B

Case pack and opinion The other file, kept separate until that organisation accepts the link.
Red team

Determination

One result, both teams The apportionment, the reasons, and what each file established.
01

Link by consent

Each insurer keeps its own case. Nothing crosses until both organisations accept the link. Either side can decline.

02

Read the joint record

Second Chair reviews both factual records, both opinions, and the underlying documents. Disagreements between the files stay visible.

03

Attack the reading

A separate red team challenges missing documents, one-sided weighting, weak authorities, and any apportionment the papers do not support.

04

Return a determination

Both teams receive the same reasoned result: the apportionment, the findings each side made out, and what remains for the handlers to decide.

The determination is for both claims teams to adopt. It does not close either claim, and it is not an award.

What you receive

One document both sides can read

The same determination goes to each claims team, so the settlement discussion starts from a shared record.

Facts found

Agreed facts, and the points where the two versions still differ.

Merit

What each side made out, and what the papers did not carry.

Documents relied on

The material the determination uses, checked before it is treated as authority.

Red-team outcome

What the attack challenged, and what still stood after that pass.

Apportionment

An indicative liability split, with the reasons beside it.

Left with the handlers

What remains for each team to decide once both have read the result.

Each firm keeps its file

A link is a share of one matter

Joining the hearing does not merge the two organisations. The controls you already set for opinions still apply to the material in the link.

Consent, both sides

Nothing from one case is available to the joint review until both organisations accept. Either side can decline.

An activity record

The record shows who linked the cases, when, and that a determination was requested.

Personal details

Personal details are stripped before anything is sent to a model.

How long it is kept

Retention follows the controls each administrator has already set for opinions and document text.

Authorities checked

A citation is verified before the determination relies on it. Unverified sources stay out.

Your file stays yours

Each organisation still owns its case. The link covers the matter in front of The Bench.

What the handlers do with it

Support for the settlement discussion

The Bench gives both claims teams a determination they can read together and adopt if they choose. A person at each insurer still records what the firm will do.

When the parties need an appointed arbitrator, a mediator, or the Ombudsman, that path remains open. Second Chair does not sit in that role.

Bring both files to the table

Tell us about a matter where two insurers are ready to hear the same determination.